Happy Times at Highroller Lobster

Time for one final post from Portland (and then we get back to talking about awesome stuff in other places). This last one is about the Highroller Lobster Co., a neat foodcart-turned-diner with a decidedly different atmosphere. It was a great way for us to cap off our visit 🙂 .

So, what made this place interesting? Well, for starters, you order your food right in front, after which you’re given a little flag with a number on it. You take this flag with you to a table (or booth) of your choosing, and then you sit and wait for your food to arrive.

Order at the front
Order at the front, sit wherever you please

Meanwhile, there’s definitely some interesting sights to take in. The décor is pure classic 50s diner, and there’s definitely artwork that highlights the seafood-centric menu.


However, by far the most interesting sight is the skeleton dressed in casual clothes, sitting by itself at one of the center tables.


As befitting a diner, the wait for the food was pretty short. The waitress found our flag (good ol’ Number 16) and dropped off our order: A crab roll and a lobster roll. Lordy, both were good, good, good 🙂 .

Sweet 16
Sweet, sweet 16

So, let’s start with why we liked the crab roll. The obvious first thing was the fact that the crab was super fresh. Beyond that, the seasoning was actually much more pronounced than in the other places we’d eaten during our time in Portland. It wasn’t overpowering, to be sure, but the marinade (or whatever it was they put in the crab) and tartness stood out more than we were expecting, and they were a very happy surprise. The flaky crab was tender and melt-in-your-mouth good. Beyond that, the bread roll was super soft and close to moist as well – it was almost less bread and more cake, which is never a bad thing 😀 .

Crab roll
Crab roll with garlic mayo and curried ketchup

Did we mention that there’s a huge list of sauces from which to choose? There are! Sauces include lime mayo, jalapeno mayo, charred pineapple mayo, garlic mayo (ok, there’s a lot of mayo 😛 ), curried ketchup, honey dijonaisse, sweet/hot relish, lobster ghee, and drawn butter.

Given our love of many, many different flavours, we tried to get sauces with different flavour profiles. That’s why we ordered curried ketchup, garlic mayo, charred pineapple mayo, and drawn butter (ok, so that last one is just more that we’re ever so slightly addicted to butter 😛 ). They were all good, especially the curried ketchup. We were, however, mildly disappointed that there wasn’t more pineapple in the pineapple mayo. Still, that’s a very minor criticism; we could both eat all four sauces all the time!

Lobster roll
Lobster roll with house slaw and potato salad
Look at all that lobster
Look at all that lobster

Moving on the lobster roll: Oh wow. The lobster in the roll came in huge chunks (as you can see from the pictures). Just like the crab, the lobster was super fresh, and the meat was both tender and springy. The sauce formed the lobster salad was really rich (but of course, we made it richer by pouring the drawn butter right on it…). Every bite of this roll was just exquisite, and we found ourselves wanting more even after it was all done [Henry: I came reeeeeeeeeeeeeal close to ordering a second one!] [Mariam: And boy, did I ever have to stop you!]

The sides were just as rich and comforting (which is the point, we guess of comfort food 😛 ]. As with everything else, the cole slaw was good and fresh (along with also being crunchy and tart and sweet). The potato salad was more subtle and subdued in its flavouring, but did it ever feel dense and filling. Top grades all around!

Overall, the food was great. We pretty much finished everything, including all the sauces (that’s always a good sign the food is good, yes? 😉 ).

All. Gone.

And with that, we started making our way back home to Montreal. We’re definitely coming back to Portland, and we’re most definitely coming back to Highroller Lobster Co.!

Where to find the Highroller Lobster Co.
Address: 104 Exchange St, Portland, ME 04101, USA
Phone: +1 207-536-1623

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s